what can be done to minimize misuse of police or legal systems in my community?

Local Involvement: Racial Bias Audits

One way communities can promote equality and work to eliminate bias within their police and legal systems is by advocating for an educated and bias free environment, starting as small as local government. An example of this completing a bias audit, which was successful in both Charleston and North Charleston, SC. These audits were conducted in January 2019 by an external non-profit (CNA), hired by the CPD to examine the organization’s policies and procedures. The CPD racial bias audit presents 48 findings and 72 recommendations for action.

What:

  • Assesses, monitors, and assists CPD in uncovering any aspect of implicit bias, systemic bias, or individual racial bias 

  • Assesses effects of enforcement operations on historically marginalized/discriminated against populations (mostly African-American communities) 

  • Provides recommendations for reform and improvement across all aspects of the community 

According to the report:

  • The final recommendation was completed by 2023 

    • 54 recommendations (80.59%) had clear evidence of implementation 

    • 11 recommendations (16.41%) had some evidence of implementation and required additional/ongoing work 

    • 2 recommendations (2.98%) had insufficient evidence of effective implementation 

    • 5 recommendations were not rated for various reasons 

      To view full report: click here > scroll down to “final report” > click “CPD FINAL REPORT”

Why important:

  • Improves community policing practices, transparency, professionalism, accountability, community inclusion and fairness, effectiveness in the community, and public trust of LE

  • Considers best practices nationally 

  • Considers community expectations of local and national LE 

  • Engages community, allows individuals to better understand their interactions and expectations of their local LE 

  • These audits and follow-up assessments can demonstrate LE’s commitment to accountability and community trust by addressing racial equity concerns and implementing reforms 

building communities of opportunity

HOW?

  • It is important for law enforcement to have strong relationships with social services to intervene. 

  • Require and incentivize the inclusion of affordable housing in new developments through:  

    • Inclusionary zoning practices  

    • Community benefits agreements 

    • Density bonuses

  • Implement equitable growth policies to reduce poverty and increase economic security - connect low income families with employment 

  • Ensure enforcement of fair housing laws 

  • Increase public and private investments in home construction - support first time buyers in finding entry homes 

  • Require federal deposit insurance corporation insured banks to provide high quality and affordable mortgage products to communities of color 

Read the full article here.

neighborhood mobility as a remedy for segregation

  • For over a century, public policies and instructional practices have excluded people of color from well-resourced and opportunity-rich neighborhoods while denying resources and investments to the neighborhoods they live in 

  • Housing vouchers and mobility programs can act as a remedy to discriminatory housing policy 

    • The flexibility they provide families to choose homes and neighborhoods that match their particular needs and preferences 

    • This gives voucher recipients more housing and more neighborhoods options than place-based public housing assistance, and in principle allows them to live in any neighborhood with voucher-affordable housing 

  • Evidence shows that housing vouchers - regardless of whether they are linked to mobility services - have a range of individual family benefits including reductions in overcrowding, in doubling up, in homelessness, in food insecurity, and in child separations and domestic violence 

  • This process led to improvements in adult mental and physical health, children’s education and behavioral outcomes. 

  • It was found that programs that combine vouchers with services intended to help voucher holders navigate their housing searches have had success.

    Read the full article here.

effects of stereotypes

  • Social class matters and, as a social construction, can be described in terms of what persons do

    • The meanings of terms such as poor, working class, low income/SES, and rich, wealthy, high income/SES all reflect different definitions and measurement.

  • Stereotypes manifest in: 

    • Child development 

    • Education 

    • Interactions outside of school 

  • This picture becomes even bleaker upon considering racial biases that often overlap class-based stereotypes 

    • Both black and white responded implicitly and explicitly associate Black targets with low-SES jobs and white targets with high SES jobs

    • Beyond educational institutions and justice systems, a nation’s economic inequality reflects and shapes its stereotypes 

    • Nations with high income-inequality display these complicated stereotype maps, which may subjectively justify and therefore stabilize their unequal systems 

    Read the full article here.